Buy or rent your primary residence?
Sep 16, 2025
3 minutes
You have your first salaries, you are finally starting to save, while paying dearly for your rent. At this stage of your life, a crucial question arises: is it better to buy or rent your primary residence? Know that you are not alone.
Well, spoiler alert: there is no single answer to this complex question.
Each solution has its advantages and disadvantages and will adapt differently to your personal needs. Your place of residence, your financial and professional goals, as well as your lifestyle will play a decisive role in this decision. Faced with a choice with such significant implications, it is essential to thoroughly explore the various aspects that will influence your choice.
The decision to buy or rent is not just a financial question; it also touches on your lifestyle and your future. Buying a house may seem like a guarantee of stability and a long-term investment, while renting offers valuable flexibility, especially in a world where professional mobility has become common. Whether you are tempted by the idea of building real estate wealth or prefer to keep options open for future opportunities, each choice presents challenges and benefits. Interest rates, real estate market prices, and even tax policies will vary based on your location, further complicating this choice. Let's take the time to examine the details of each option to provide you with an informed perspective for your unique situation.
Buy or rent? A common dilemma
When considering acquiring a property, whether it is a purchase or a rental, it is crucial to understand the implications of each option. For a purchase, be prepared to assess your budget, obtain financing such as a mortgage, and carefully review the legal documents related to the property. In contrast, for a rental, focus on preparing your tenant file, which often includes proof of income and references, as well as understanding the terms of the lease. In both cases, it is essential to thoroughly evaluate your needs and financial capabilities to make an informed choice.
Renting in 2025: advantages and constraints
The evolution of the real estate market in major French cities
The rental real estate market in major French cities like Paris, Lyon, Lille, and Marseille has become increasingly complex. These cities, once sought after for their economic and cultural dynamism, are now witnessing a true race for rentals. In Paris, for example, the market is characterized by a colossal demand that far exceeds the supply.
The phenomenon of rental tension is explained by several factors. On one hand, the economic attractiveness of these metropolises attracts new residents every year, thus increasing the pressure on the existing rental stock. On the other hand, households' budget constraints, linked to wage stagnation and the rising cost of living, make the search more difficult. This situation forces tenants to double their efforts to build solid applications and potentially to broaden their searches to neighborhoods that were previously less popular.
The challenges tenants face with income requirements
In a tight market, the issue of the budget allocated to housing becomes crucial. A prevalent rule in the sector is the requirement for potential tenants to justify an income equivalent to three times the amount of the rent. This criterion, although aimed at guaranteeing the solvency of tenants, nevertheless excludes a large part of the population, notably young professionals and precarious workers.
Landlords, seeking to minimize the risk of unpaid rent, are often strict regarding these selection criteria. This forces many individuals to turn to alternative solutions, such as shared accommodation or the use of guarantors. Schemes like the Visale guarantee have been put in place to provide additional security to landlords while offering assistance to tenants who do not meet standard criteria.
Regulations and assistance to encourage access to housing
In the face of tension in the rental market, municipal and governmental administrations have implemented measures to regulate rents in an attempt to relieve tenants. Cities like Paris and Lille have instituted rent controls, limiting price increases and making certain areas more accessible.
Additionally, several housing assistance programs are available for households in difficulty, such as personal housing assistance (APL) and grants for energy renovation, which can lighten the financial burden on households. However, these initiatives sometimes struggle to reach all those in need, and their application remains complex.
In this context, the continuous revision of public policies and dialogue among the various stakeholders in the sector are essential to improving access to housing. Future reforms will need to take into account the economic realities of tenants while encouraging responsible investment by landlords.
Buying in 2025: feasible with a significant initial contribution
Buying a property in 2025 may seem more accessible at first glance, but this decision is far from straightforward. The real estate market continues to fluctuate, and although interest rates may appear attractive, borrowers must navigate through a sea of restrictive financial conditions. One of the main obstacles is the requirement for a significant deposit, which is often difficult to gather for many potential buyers, especially first-time buyers. This initial deposit generally represents a high percentage of the total property price and constitutes an important barrier to entering the real estate market.
Moreover, borrowing capacity remains limited by a strict rule: the maximum amount that can be borrowed must not exceed one third of net monthly income. This limitation can considerably reduce purchasing power, especially in areas where real estate prices are high. As a result, even those who manage to gather sufficient funds may find themselves compelled to lower their ambitions regarding property location or size. Thus, despite an apparent simplicity, purchasing real estate in 2025 will require rigorous financial planning and consideration of several constraining factors.
The actual costs: a detailed comparison between buying and renting
The Costs of Renting: Apparent Simplicity, Recurring Fees
The appeal of renting may seem obvious at first glance: it offers a flexible housing solution without the long-term commitment that comes with purchasing a property. However, beneath its apparent simplicity lie various recurring fees that can accumulate over time, making renting an option that can sometimes be more expensive than expected.
First of all, the monthly rent constitutes the main and most visible cost. Depending on the location, the amenities offered, and the size of the accommodation, this amount can vary considerably. Large cities and desirable neighborhoods often feature higher rents, significantly impacting the monthly budget of tenants.
Next, there are the rental charges. They include payment forcommunity services such as water, collective heating, maintenance of common areas, and sometimes waste removal. These charges can be included in the rent or separated, requiring special attention to understand exactly what is covered and what is not.
Tenants must also anticipatethe cost of homeowners insurance, often required by landlords to cover any potential damage to the property. Although generally less expensive than landlord insurance, it is nonetheless another recurring cost to consider.
Additionally, there may be agency fees for managing or renewing the lease, which can vary from one provider to another. Security deposits, although refundable, also represent a considerable sum tied up during the rental period. For a simple example, if you rent a furnished property for €1,000 per month, you would need to have a security deposit of €2,000.
Finally, let’s not forget the potential rent increases. Many leases include an annual revision clause based on the rent reference index. Although these increases are often moderate, they accumulate over the years, gradually increasing the cost of housing.
In summary, renting offers a flexible housing solution, but it is not without hidden costs and recurring fees. It is therefore crucial for tenants to understand and anticipate these expenses to choose the solution that best fits their financial situation and long-term goals.
The Costs of Buying: A Heavy Investment in Hidden and Recurring Fees
Purchasing a property represents a significant and often complex investment, largely due to the hidden and recurring fees that can considerably inflate the final bill. One of the crucial distinctions to make concerns the fee disparity between old and new real estate, influencing not only the initial costs but also the long-term financial experience of the homeowner.
Notary Fees: Old vs. New
When it comes to purchasing real estate, notary fees - often viewed as one of the most significant costs - vary considerably depending on whether the property is old or new. In the case of old real estate, these fees generally account for around 7 to 8% of the property's price. These percentages include various elements such as registration fees, disbursements, and of course, the notary's remuneration. In contrast, new properties benefit from a significant reduction in notary fees, which generally amount to around 2 to 3%. Although this may seem minor, this difference can quickly represent thousands of euros in savings, making new real estate particularly attractive for buyers looking to reduce their initial costs.
Real Estate Loans and Interest Rates
Another crucial aspect of real estate purchasing relates to financing via real estate loans. The choice of loan, whether fixed or variable rate, directly influences the total cost of the purchase. In periods of low real estate rates, opting for a fixed rate may seem attractive to ensure stable monthly payments. However, one must remain cautious and consider the economic conditions likely to result in rate fluctuations, thus impacting repayment capacity over the long term.
Additionally, the duration of the loan remains a determining factor: a short loan can help reduce the overall cost of borrowing despite higher monthly payments, while a longer term increases the total cost while lowering monthly payments. Therefore, buying requires careful evaluation of financial capabilities to avoid financial pitfalls.
Capital Gains on Real Estate
Finally, when a property is sold, the issue of capital gains tax comes into play. The tax related to the capital gain can vary depending on the duration of property ownership. Generally, beyond 22 years of ownership, the capital gain is exempt from income tax, and after 30 years, it is exempt from social charges, making the calculation of the opportunity to sell potentially advantageous for homeowners planning their long-term profit. However, fluctuations in the real estate market can make predicting these gains uncertain.
In summary, purchasing real estate engages many reflections and strategic calculations regarding immediate and long-term fees. A well-planned approach, taking into account the nature of the property and financing conditions, can not only alleviate the burden of initial costs but also optimize profitability and financial security over the long term.
The Other Hidden Fees
When purchasing a property, it is essential not to be caught off guard by hidden fees that can quickly inflate the final bill. In addition to the purchase price, various additional costs, such as notary fees, condominium charges, and potential local taxes, can accumulate and significantly impact your budget.
- Application fees related to obtaining the real estate loan, prepare an average of €1,000 to €5,000 extra.
- Property tax, an annual mandatory expense for all homeowners, check out our article on property tax.
- Costs for repairs and current maintenance of the property, including unexpected work and maintenance.
- Condominium charges, for properties in condominium, including maintenance of common areas, elevator fees, and collective heating.
- Household waste tax, the TOEM, you are liable for it.
- Homeowner's insurance, essential for protection against various risks, anticipate between €20 and €150 per month.
- Facade renovation, often required by the municipality at regular intervals, representing a substantial expense. A facade renovation can cost a condominium between €700,000 and €2 million.
All these elements are additional costs to anticipate beyond the loan monthly payments for optimal budget management when purchasing real estate.
The long-term financial dimension – Wealth and investment strategies
The 5% rule in real estate: a practical guide to deciding between buying and renting
To assess whether renting your primary residence is financially more advantageous than buying, you can use a simple method based on the 5% rule. Here are the steps to follow:
Calculate the total price of the property. This includes the purchase price, notary fees (approximately 10% of the purchase price), and any renovation costs.
Multiply this total price by 5% to estimate the unrecoverable annual costs, which consist of:
0.5% for property tax
1% for maintenance
3.5% for the cost of capital
Divide the result by twelve to obtain the equivalent monthly cost of unrecoverable charges.
Compare this amount with the rent of a similar property.
If the rent is lower than this amount, renting could be financially more advantageous.
If the rent is higher, you can reverse the rule to estimate the purchase price of a property whose ownership costs would equal your current rent.
Practical Example
Let's take the example of a property whose total cost (including notary fees and renovations) is €300,000. The non-recoverable annual charges would be 5% of this amount, which is €15,000, equivalent to about €1,250 per month.
Scenario: If you find a similar property to rent for less than €1,250 per month, then renting would likely be the better financial option.
This 5% rule helps you make an informed decision by simply comparing the monthly rental and acquisition costs.
Renting Out Your Primary Residence to Invest Elsewhere
More and more homeowners are choosing to rent out their primary residence in order to free up cash for investments elsewhere. This strategy, although unconventional, offers several advantages both financially and for asset diversification. Let's see why this option attracts the attention of savvy investors and how it can be effectively implemented.
Why Rent Out Your Primary Residence?
First, renting out your primary residence allows for the generation of immediate passive income. This source of income can be particularly advantageous in areas where rental real estate is in high demand, enabling the homeowner to receive rent that exceeds their monthly expenses. Furthermore, this decision can release funds that would otherwise be tied up in a property, thus providing necessary liquidity to seize other investment opportunities.
Diversification of Investments
Renting out your primary residence also represents an opportunity for diversification. Rather than concentrating the majority of one’s wealth in a single property, the homeowner can reinvest the rental proceeds in different assets. This could include purchasing additional real estate, investing in financial markets, or even taking stakes in companies. This diversification reduces the risk associated with reliance on a single type of asset and can also enhance the potential for long-term returns.
Potential Tax Advantages
From a tax perspective, renting out your primary residence can allow you to benefit from certain tax advantages, including deductions related to rental properties that are not available for primary residences. It is important to consult a tax expert to fully understand the tax implications of this strategy and ensure that it aligns with your financial goals.
How to Optimize This Strategy?
To make the most of this strategy, it is crucial to accurately assess the local rental market in order to set a competitive rent that attracts tenants while maximizing income. Additionally, regular and proactive maintenance of the property is essential to preserve its value and avoid costly repair fees. Finally, wisely choosing where to reinvest the funds is a key step to ensure that this strategy leads to an increase in overall wealth.
In conclusion, renting out your primary residence to invest elsewhere can be a prudent financial strategy for those seeking to diversify their assets and optimize their portfolio. However, like any investment decision, it requires careful assessment and informed planning to ensure long-term success.
Transforming Your Primary Residence into a Rental Property
Transforming your primary residence into a rental property is an attractive option for many homeowners looking to capitalize on their real estate investment. This strategy can offer various advantages, both financially and tax-wise, but it also requires a thorough understanding of certain legal and economic considerations.
Motivations Behind the Transformation
Several reasons may prompt a homeowner to convert their primary residence into a rental property. Firstly, moving to a new residence, whether for professional, personal, or economic reasons, may leave the property unoccupied. Rather than selling the old home, renting it out can generate passive income while allowing the homeowner to retain the real estate asset, which could continue to appreciate over time.
Moreover, in certain economic contexts, renting may be more advantageous than selling, especially if real estate market prices are declining. Renting allows for delaying a sale while waiting for a potential rebound in prices.
Legal and Tax Considerations
It is crucial to be aware of the legal and tax implications before transforming a primary residence into a rental property. In France, for example, administrative steps may be necessary, including a declaration to the town hall in case of a change in the property’s use.
On the tax side, renting a property can lead to a change in real estate taxation. The received rents must be declared and will be subject to income tax. However, there are also advantageous tax provisions for landlord homeowners, such as the micro-property scheme or the actual regime, which allow for certain expenses to be deducted from rental income.
The Rental Market and Its Risks
Before renting out their primary residence, it is essential to study the local rental market. Is demand strong in the area? What is the average rent for a similar property? Answering these questions can help assess the potential profitability of this operation.
Furthermore, becoming a landlord carries certain risks, such as rental payment defaults or damages caused by tenants. It is advisable to take out rent default insurance to protect against these uncertainties. Additionally, drafting a solid rental contract that complies with current legislation is essential to prevent future disputes.
Selling Your Rental Investment to Purchase Your Primary Residence
When a homeowner decides to sell their rental property, they may consider using the proceeds from that sale to acquire their primary residence. This strategy offers several financial and tax advantages, particularly concerning capital gains taxation. French legislation indeed provides an interesting opportunity for those who wish to quickly reinvest in their primary residence after selling their rental property.
In France, capital gains realized upon the sale of a property are generally subject to tax, which can represent a significant cost. However, there is a conditional exemption that may benefit sellers. If the homeowner reinvests the proceeds from the sale into the purchase of their primary residence within two years, they are exempt from capital gains tax. This exemption aims to encourage the transition from rental investment to direct ownership and can constitute a major financial incentive for those hesitating between keeping their rental property or making the leap to purchasing their primary residence.
By carefully planning this transition, the homeowner can not only optimize their tax situation but also align their finances with their personal and family goals. To benefit from this exemption, it is essential to adhere to the two-year timeline and properly document each step of the transaction. Consulting a tax advisor or notary can be wise to ensure that all conditions are met and that the transition occurs in compliance with current legislation. Thus, selling a rental investment to buy a primary residence can be not only a strategic move but also tax-wise advantageous.
Concrete example: In Paris, choosing to rent is significantly more beneficial than buying a primary residence.
Deciding between buying or renting your primary residence is a major decision that can influence your budget and quality of life. Let’s explore this question in detail by relying on concrete examples.
The Parisian Context
In a dynamic city like Paris, the question of whether it is better to buy or rent becomes even more important. Here are some figures to illustrate the situation:
- Average rent for a 50 m² apartment in Paris: around €1,700 per month.
- Purchase price for the same apartment: between €450,000 and €700,000, with an average of €500,000 (around €10,000 per m²).
- Repayment of a mortgage for this purchase: approximately €3,000 per month.
Why Renting May Be More Advantageous
- Affordable cost: Renting is still cheaper with a rent that is almost half the monthly mortgage repayment.
- Geographical flexibility: Renting offers the possibility to change neighborhoods or cities more easily.
- Fewer financial constraints: No notary fees or property taxes to bear.
Recommended Strategy: Rent and Invest in Rental Properties
Renting your primary residence can be a financially prudent strategy. Here are some reasons:
- Optimized borrowing capacity: Use this capacity to invest in rental properties, which can generate additional income.
- Diversified assets: Rental investment can allow you to build real estate wealth without being tied down by a primary residence.
Additional Costs to Consider When Buying
- Notary fees: Significant and must be paid with each purchase.
- Mortgage and interest: Costs can exceed initial forecasts, especially if interest rates rise.
Conclusion
In a city like Paris, renting can offer more flexibility while allowing the building of wealth through rental property investments. Of course, every situation is unique, and it is crucial to carefully weigh the options based on your personal and financial needs.
Also discover
