Acquiring one's family residence is often a lifetime investment. Yet, behind the emotion and the project of stability lies a determining legal and tax decision. Buying one's family home through a SCI is not just a simple technical setup: it is a strategic choice that influences inheritance, spousal protection, child management, and the overall organization of wealth. When used well, the SCI becomes a powerful tool. If poorly managed, it can increase the taxation and unnecessarily complicate management.
The feasibility of buying one's family home in a real estate investment company (SCI)
Primary residence or rental investment
The first question to resolve concerns the nature of the property. Buying your family home in SCI does not have the same effects as a rental investment. In the case of a primary residence held directly, the owner benefits from a total exemption on capital gains in the event of resale. This protective regime disappears when the property is held through a property management company.
The SCI is legally the owner of the property. The partners hold shares, not the house itself. If the house is occupied by one of the partners, the tax authorities may consider that they benefit from an in-kind advantage if no compensation is paid. In practice, some families organize a rent or a structured provision, but this must be consistent with the social purpose.
In concrete terms, buying your family home in SCI is often more of a patrimonial choice than a simple real estate purchase. The objective is no longer just to live in it but to structure the ownership of the property over time, particularly to anticipate a transfer or avoid joint ownership.
Conditions for buying your family home in SCI
Legally, an SCI requires at least two partners. It can be a couple, parents with an adult child, or members of the same family. The social purpose must clearly indicate the acquisition and management of real estate.
It is essential that the SCI be established before the final signature at the notary's office if one wishes for the company to be the owner from the outset. This involves drafting the articles of association, publishing a legal notice, and registering with the trade and companies register. Without this chronology, the property would be acquired directly and then possibly contributed to the SCI, a more costly operation.
Banks also examine the coherence of the project. Buying your family home in SCI almost systematically requires that the partners personally guarantee the loan. The company is merely a legal screen: the financial risk remains borne by the individuals.
Profiles for which the SCI is relevant
The SCI is not suitable for all situations. It makes the most sense in a structured and anticipated family framework. Blended families find it to be an effective tool for organizing everyone's rights and avoiding succession blockages. Parents wishing to gradually transfer their real estate assets can also optimize their strategy through donations of shares.
It is particularly relevant when several generations wish to hold a common property. Rather than buying in joint ownership, a situation often fraught with conflict, the SCI offers clear and adaptable operating rules.
On the other hand, for a couple without an objective of early transmission and simply wishing to buy their primary residence, the SCI may add unnecessary administrative and tax complexity. The management costs, accounting obligations, and lack of automatic capital gains exemption should be carefully evaluated before any decision.
The steps to buy your family home in a real estate investment company (SCI)
The creation of the SCI before the acquisition
The chronology is crucial. To buy the family home in SCI under optimal conditions, the company must exist legally before signing the authentic deed at the notary's office. Otherwise, the property will be acquired in the individual's name and subsequently transferred to the SCI, which incurs additional costs (registration fees, notary fees, formalities).
The creation involves several successive steps: drafting the bylaws, depositing the share capital, publishing a legal announcement, and then registration in the trade and companies register. The bylaws must already anticipate the family project, as they will govern the management of the property, the powers of the manager, and the conditions for the entry or exit of a partner.
One strategic point deserves attention: the sales agreement can be signed “on behalf of the SCI in formation.” This technique allows reserving the property during the formation phase. However, it requires that the company be registered before the final deed for the acquisition to be perfectly secured.
Financing the family home in SCI
Financing is often the most sensitive step. Buying the family home in SCI does not erase the banking reality: the solvency of the partners remains the central element of the analysis of the file.
Several levers are possible. Partners can make capital contributions, thereby limiting the need for borrowing. They can also advance funds through a partner current account, a flexible solution allowing financing part of the acquisition without increasing the share capital. Finally, the SCI can take out a traditional mortgage.
In practice, banks almost always require a personal guarantee from the partners or even a mortgage on the property. This means that financial responsibility exceeds the theoretical framework of the company. Before committing, it is essential to assess each person's repayment capacity and anticipate the consequences in case of separation, death, or disagreement.
Bylaws adapted to the family project
The bylaws are the true backbone of the project. Buying the family home in SCI without tailor-made drafting amounts to laying the foundations for a future conflict. Each clause must reflect the reality of the asset project.
The approval clause, for example, allows controlling the entry of a new partner. It is fundamental in the event of divorce or succession. The majority rules must also be carefully considered: is unanimity required to sell the property? Is a qualified majority sufficient? These choices directly influence family stability.
It is also possible to organize the manager's powers, foresee specific protection clauses for the spouse, or frame the valuation of shares in case of buyout. A practical advice is to work on these bylaws with a notary or a specialized lawyer to perfectly align the legal tool with the asset objective.
The signing of the deed in the name of the SCI
At the time of the final signing, the notary verifies the legal existence of the company and the powers of the manager. The authentic deed will mention the SCI as the buyer, indicating its registration and legal representative.
From the moment of this signature, the house legally belongs to the SCI. The partners only own social shares. This distinction is essential, especially in the event of death or transfer: it is not real estate rights that are transferred, but shares of the company.
Finally, it should be noted that the partners of a real estate company (SCI) are indefinitely liable for corporate debts, in proportion to their shares. Buying the family home in an SCI protects the asset organization, but does not completely isolate from financial risk.
The tax consequences of a family home in a real estate investment company
Income tax or corporate tax
Choosing the tax regime is one of the most significant decisions when deciding to buy a family home in a real estate company (SCI). By default, the SCI is subject to income tax (IR). This means that any potential results are taxed directly in the hands of the partners, proportionally to their shares.
In the context of a family home occupied by the partners, the SCI under IR generally does not generate taxable income, unless rent is paid. However, the taxation becomes crucial in case of resale: the partners then benefit from the capital gains regime for individuals, with progressive allowances based on the duration of ownership. This point can represent a significant advantage in the long term.
Conversely, opting for corporate tax (IS) profoundly alters the asset management logic. The company is taxed on its profits, and the capital gain is calculated according to professional rules, after amortization of the asset. While amortization helps reduce the taxable base during ownership, it mechanically increases the taxable capital gain upon resale. Buying a family home in SCI under IS can therefore increase the taxation in case of sale, especially if the goal is to retain the property for a long time before transferring it.
The choice between IR and IS thus depends on the overall strategy: long-term ownership and family transmission often favor IR, while a logic of accounting optimization or rental management may justify IS. A prior numerical simulation is essential to avoid an irreversible and penalizing decision.
Resale and capital gains taxation
Resale constitutes the true tax test of the arrangement. When the SCI is subject to income tax, the capital gain is calculated as it would be for an individual. The acquisition price is compared to the selling price, applying progressive allowances beyond five years of ownership. Ultimately, total exemption is obtained after a sufficiently long period. This mechanism can make the choice to buy a family home in SCI from an intergenerational perspective coherent.
On the other hand, under the corporate tax regime, the capital gain is included in the taxable income. The calculation takes into account the net book value, that is, the acquisition price reduced by applied amortizations. The longer the duration of ownership, the higher the taxable base may be. Taxation can then be significantly higher than that applicable to individuals.
An additional point of attention concerns the distribution of the proceeds from the sale. If the SCI under IS realizes a capital gain and then distributes the funds to the partners, they may be taxed a second time on the dividends. This mechanism of double taxation must be anticipated from the outset of the project.
Thus, buying a family home in a SCI requires planning for the exit from the very beginning. The taxation is not limited to annual ownership; it is assessed over the entire life cycle of the property.
The property effects of a family home in a real estate investment company (SCI)
The gradual transfer of shares
One of the main advantages of buying your family home through a real estate investment company (SCI) lies in the flexibility of transmission. Unlike a property held directly, it is possible to gradually give shares to your children while retaining control over management.
The technique of dismemberment is particularly effective. Parents can transfer the bare ownership of the shares while retaining the usufruct, which means the right to receive potential income and participate in important decisions. This strategy allows for reducing the taxable base through allowances that can be renewed every fifteen years, while preparing for succession in a gradual and controlled manner.
Practically speaking, this approach also avoids the physical fragmentation of the property. The house remains legally intact, but the value is distributed in the form of shares. Buying your family home in an SCI thus facilitates an anticipated, smooth, and tax-optimized transmission.
The protection of the spouse and children
The SCI offers great freedom of organization. The statutes can allocate specific voting rights, organize the distribution of powers, or include protective clauses in case of death. This flexibility is valuable in blended families or when the goal is to ensure the stability of the surviving spouse.
It is possible, for example, to provide that the spouse retains management or benefits from usufruct on the shares. This guarantees a continuation of residence and ongoing management while respecting the succession rights of the children. Without an adapted structure, joint ownership can quickly become a source of tension, especially when multiple heirs must make decisions unanimously.
Buying your family home in an SCI thus allows for anticipating succession balances. Rather than being subjected to legal rules, the family defines its own operating framework, thereby limiting the risks of blockage and instability.
Anticipating conflicts and the exit of partners
Any wealth organization must take into account the possibility of disagreement. Divorce, disputes among heirs, need for liquidity: situations evolve. The SCI allows these events to be framed through precise clauses.
The approval clause prevents the free transfer of shares to an unwanted third party. Buyout mechanisms can be established, with valuation methods set in advance to avoid disputes. It is also possible to organize adapted majority rules to prevent a minority partner from blocking an essential decision.
Buying one's family home in a SCI does not eliminate the risk of conflict, but it allows for legal channeling. While joint ownership often requires unanimity, civil society offers a more flexible and predictable framework, a true tool for long-term wealth stability.
Conclusion
Buying a family home through a real estate company (SCI) is a strategic choice that goes well beyond simple property acquisition. This legal tool allows for organizing ownership, facilitating transfer, protecting the spouse, and anticipating conflicts, all while offering valuable statutory flexibility. However, the taxation, banking constraints, and responsibilities of partners require careful prior consideration. Well thought out and adapted to the family project, the SCI becomes a true lever of wealth engineering; poorly calibrated, it can instead unnecessarily complicate the management of a property that should primarily be a place of stability.
Also discover
